Why Business Transformation Isn't DIY

Why Business Transformation Isn't DIY

  
Published in Switched On: The Bowdark Blog -
Business Transformation
Digital Transformation
IT Strategy
Bowdark Lighthouse

There’s a natural temptation for leadership teams to treat business transformation like weekend home projects. With all the recent advances in technology, how hard can it really be? You attend a conference or two, skim a few analyst reports, see some compelling demos, and suddenly the path forward feels obvious. At this point, it’s easy to fall into the trap of viewing transformation as a do-it-yourself exercise: buy the right platforms, assign a few internal champions, and trust that momentum will carry the rest.

Figure 1: Weekend Home Projects Are Never as Easy as Advertised

On paper, it all makes sense. After all, who knows the business better than the people already running it? But much like assembling IKEA® furniture, business transformation has a way of looking deceptively straightforward until you’re in the middle of it staring at leftover parts, mounting frustration, and the realization that something important was underestimated. The truth is this: transformation isn’t a side project. When done properly, transformation calls for a complete operating model shift that requires sustained focus, dedicated ownership, and continuous improvement.

The Myth: Knowing the Business Is the Same as Knowing How to Transform It

This myth isn’t completely wrong. However, for most organizations, it’s incomplete.

Your internal teams absolutely understand your customers, processes, and institutional history better than anyone else. That knowledge is essential. But knowing the business is not the same thing as knowing how to use technology to change it safely, sustainably, and at scale.

Successful transformation requires capabilities that most organizations don’t have in-house or exercise regularly, including:

  • Cross-functional coordination across teams with competing priorities.

  • Deep technical know-how and architectural decision-making that impacts the business for years.

  • Change management that addresses behavior, incentives, and adoption.

  • Governance models that balance agility with control.

According to McKinsey, nearly 70% of large-scale transformation initiatives fail, often due to lack of focus, insufficient capabilities, or underestimating organizational resistance to change. The good news is that the odds improve dramatically when leaders acknowledge those realities and put real support behind the effort. Clear ownership, experienced guidance, and the capacity to stay focused day in and day out help turn transformation from a risky side initiative into something the organization can actually sustain and succeed at.

Figure 2: Executive-Level Support is Essential for Success

Transformation Always Competes with the Day Job

As noted in the last section, one of the most common reasons DIY transformation efforts stall is capacity. Or more accurately, the lack thereof.

In practice, transformation initiatives are typically layered on top of existing job responsibilities. The same leaders and teams tasked with running the business are asked to redesign it at the same time. Inevitably, when priorities collide, transformation loses.

Quarter-end deadlines appear. Customer issues escalate. Systems misbehave. Regulatory requirements shift. And the transformation roadmap quietly slides to the right.

Figure 3: Business Engagement is Crucial for Transformation Projects, But There's Only So Many Hours in the Day

This is why so many initiatives don’t fail outright. They linger. They stall. They fragment into disconnected pilots that never quite add up to real change.

Gartner has repeatedly pointed out that organizations underestimate the sustained effort required to move from strategy to execution. Transformation doesn’t fail because of lack of vision. It fails because no one is truly dedicated to carrying that vision across the finish line.

Tools Don’t Transform Businesses—Operating Models Do

Modern technology platforms are powerful. Cloud services, low-code tools, analytics, and AI can absolutely accelerate change. But tools like this can’t transform your business on their own.

Figure 4: Technology is Powerful, But It's Not a Silver Bullet

Most transformation challenges show up after the technology is selected:

  • Who owns decisions when trade-offs arise?

  • How do teams prioritize work across functions?

  • What gets standardized versus customized?

  • How do changes actually make it into day-to-day workflows?

This is where many DIY efforts really start to unravel. Without clear ownership and proven patterns, organizations tend to over-customize, move too slowly, or optimize for short-term wins at the expense of long-term sustainability.

Experienced transformation teams bring something tools never will: pattern recognition. They’ve seen what works, what breaks, and what quietly becomes technical or organizational debt six months later.

Change is a Human Problem First

If technology were the hardest part of transformation, most initiatives would succeed. In reality, the hardest part about transformation is that it involves and impacts people.

New systems change how work gets done. They challenge habits, roles, and sometimes identities. Even positive change creates friction when it disrupts familiar routines.

That's why so many well-intentioned initiatives stall at the adoption phase of the project. The system works, but people revert to spreadsheets because they're easier. Dashboards exist, but decisions are still made based on gut feel. Automation is available, but manual workarounds persist.

Successful transformation treats change management as a core workstream, not an afterthought. That means:

  • Engaging with and involving stakeholders early and often

  • Designing with real users in real work settings, not idealized ones

  • Sequencing change to avoid fatigue

  • Reinforcing new behaviors through leadership and incentives

These are learned skills. And they’re rarely developed by teams already stretched thin running the business.

Why External Experience Matters

When transformation efforts start to stall, some organizations swing to the opposite extreme. Instead of trying to do everything themselves, they throw up their hands and hand transformation off entirely to an outside consulting firm—effectively stepping back and waiting for change to be delivered to them.

This approach rarely works either. Transformation isn’t something that can be installed, delegated, or completed in isolation from the people who run the business every day. When internal teams are disengaged, initiatives lose context, adoption suffers, and any progress made is difficult to sustain once the consultants leave.

Organizations that succeed at transformation tend to pair deep internal knowledge with external teams that bring:

  • Dedicated execution capacity

  • Proven delivery frameworks

  • Objective perspectives during tough decisions

  • The ability to translate strategy into shipped outcomes

External partners aren't meant to replace internal teams. Instead, they should amplify them. They provide momentum, guardrails, and a steady hand when complexity increases. Think of it less like hiring contractors and more like bringing in a coach while your team stays on the field.

The Most Successful Transformations Share One Trait

Across industries, the most successful transformations tend to have one thing in common: they are treated as a first-class initiative, not a side hustle.

That means:

  • Clear ownership and accountability

  • Dedicated teams with protected time

  • Realistic roadmaps grounded in operational reality

  • A willingness to invest in execution, not just planning

Organizations that recognize this early avoid the slow bleed of stalled initiatives, half-adopted tools, and transformation fatigue.

You Need a New Kind of Partner

At this point, you might be wondering: if business transformation isn’t something we can—or should—do entirely on our own, then who can I get to help me? And what does the right kind of help look like?

Traditional consulting models tend to fall into one of two extremes:

  • On one end, you have advisory-heavy engagements that deliver thoughtful strategies and roadmaps, but leave execution largely in the hands of already overextended internal teams.

  • On the other, you have large, project-based delivery models that take over wholesale, driving progress in the short term but often leaving organizations dependent, disconnected, or struggling to sustain momentum once the engagement ends.

Neither model is well suited to the reality most organizations face today, where transformation is continuous, priorities shift constantly, and the “finish line” keeps moving.

That’s why you need a different kind of partner. One that doesn’t replace your team or dictate change from the outside, but embeds alongside it. A partner that brings focus, experience, and execution capacity, while keeping ownership and accountability where it belongs—with the business.

This is the gap that our Lighthouse service was designed to fill.

Lighthouse provides an ongoing operating model for transformation, not a one-time project. It blends external experience with internal context, pairing seasoned practitioners across ERP, CRM, data, and custom development with your existing teams. The result is sustained progress that doesn’t stall when day-to-day pressures resurface, and transformation that becomes part of how the organization operates, not something bolted on after the fact.

Figure 5: What's Included with Our Lighthouse Build Model

Through Lighthouse, we embed alongside your internal teams to provide:

  • Dedicated execution capacity without expanding headcount

  • Experienced leadership across ERP, CRM, data, and custom development

  • Practical governance that keeps modernization moving without breaking what works

  • A steady cadence of improvement instead of stop-and-start initiatives

Our goal isn’t just to “do transformation for you.” It’s to make transformation sustainable so progress doesn’t stall when priorities shift or internal teams get pulled back into day-to-day operations.

For organizations that are ready to move forward but don’t want to gamble on another DIY effort, Lighthouse provides the structure, experience, and continuity needed to turn strategy into lasting change.

The Bottom Line

Business transformation isn’t DIY because it’s:

  • Too complex to improvise

  • Too important to run part-time

  • And too human to be solved with technology alone

The winners aren’t the organizations that adopt the most tools or chase the latest trends. They’re the ones that build the capability to change—intentionally, continuously, and with discipline.

Transformation isn’t about building something new. It’s about changing how the business runs.

And that’s not a weekend project.

About the Author

James Wood headshot
James Wood

Best-selling author and SAP Mentor alumnus James Wood is CEO of Bowdark Consulting, a management consulting firm focused on optimizing customers' business processes using Microsoft, SAP, and cloud-based technologies. James' 25 years in software engineering gives him a deep understanding of enterprise software. Before co-founding Bowdark in 2006, James was a senior technology consultant at SAP America and IBM, where he was involved in multiple global implementation projects.

An error has occurred. This application may no longer respond until reloaded. Reload 🗙